"We learned many lessons here at the Lynnwood Police Department on the heels of this investigation," Cohnheim acknowledged. Maher asked. "And they see the truck leave. Join Facebook to connect with Marc O Leary and others you may know. He instructed her, you know, to use soap, to use toothpaste, to basically wash away, or take away any of the evidence that we needed to -- to solve the case.". The descriptions of the attacker were similar. "48 Hours" correspondent Maureen Maher has a rare look inside the mind of this predator, and the female detectives determined to hunt him down before he could strike again. She had responded to a report of a rape at an apartment complex in the northwest of her city. And at one point, she said that it didn't happen," Commander Cohnheim said. In the show, his name was Christopher McCarthy. He watched as she awoke. He climbed on top of her, tied her up, cut off her clothes and for the next four hours, brutally raped her. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: checked out her house a couple of times. Among those items was a hard drive full of photographs that he had taken of his victims. Two police officers from different precincts banded together to find him after his DNA linked him to multiple crime scenes. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: I got some satisfaction. "No," Marie told him, her voice soft, her eyes down. Whatever he told me to do, I did it," she said. He looked like Marc O'Leary. Ontario Court Justice Richard Humphrey, shown in a court sketch, reads his verdict over Zoom on Tuesday at the . "This is a pink, Sony Cyber-shot camera that was collected from the office of O'Leary's residence," Galbraith explained. But Mary is hoping other victims of O'Leary's will come forward. It was a picture of the woman's learner's driving licence, placed on her chest. He planned to install a surveillance camera nearby and wanted to make sure that nobody was around. The case also formed the basis for a book, A False Report: A True Story of Rape in America published in 2018, and was explored in an episode of the This American Life podcast. I wonder if he's gone,'" Mary replied. In the bedroom, Marie seemed casual, with nothing to suggest that something horrible had happened there. She asked that her current location not be disclosed. Her strength fuels the work Galbraith and Hendershot have committed their lives to. We-- we got him.' The three then went to the police station so Marie could recant her recantation - that is, tell detectives that she had been telling the truth the first time. First thing the next morning, her husband put her in touch with Detective Edna Hendershot, the lead investigator on that case 19 miles away in Westminster, Colo. "It seemed pretty obvious that there was some connection," said Det. He warned her not to come out of the bathroom until he left. Even her foster parents doubted her. "I just lived moment to moment. Watch Live: Closing arguments underway in double murder trial of Alex Murdaugh, Top McCarthy aide, House Oversight chair each met with Ashli Babbitt's mother, Colon cancer rates rising in younger age group, study finds, Garland testifies before Senate panel amid ongoing special counsel probes, Ex-Georgia star Jalen Carter was racing in deadly crash, arrest warrants allege, Fiery train crash in Greece kills dozens, many of them students. "Trying to figure out what is it they have in common that would make them targets for this particular individual, that was very frustrating.". "Correct," Grusing replied. And when the two went to buy new bedding - Marie's old bedding having been taken as evidence - Marie became furious when she couldn't find the same set. Maher asked. It was the exact camera that was stolen from the Westminster victim and used to photograph the Golden victim. "That's our guy," Galbraith said. The Westminster victim was 59 years old," Det. Galbraith said. The woman's charge was expunged from her record, her fine was reimbursed and she eventually settled a lawsuit with the police department for $150,000. In October of 2009, Mary, a 65-year old grandmother, was jarred awake by a large masked man. Starting in 2008, he continued that trend but also began to hurt and rape the women who were home alone at the time. In her case, it was because of the trauma brought on by the rape. In O'Leary's phone, they found that he had called one woman numerous times. "If you didn't own energy in the last 18 months, you missed the market," he said in a recent interview. And then he raped her for a period of time," said Lynwood Police Department Commander Rodney Cohnheim. Boston New York City Houston Chicago Los Angeles . Snow covered the ground in patches. We knocked on that white door where the light is," Grusing told Maher as they stood in front of O'Leary's house. He gained entry through an unlocked sliding door. "She shattered her vertebra, that two ribs were broken, and her lung was punctured from that fall. Galbraith recounted the day's events. Honeycomb marks. And it looks like the registered owner gets in it with a female," said Det. Marie - that's her middle name - didn't say anything. As a result of her false-reporting conviction, Marie lost a lot of friends. As part of the team followed the couple to lunch at a restaurant, Grusing stayed behind, hoping to install a surveillance camera on the house. They decided to run Michael's DNA, collected from the restaurant cup, against DNA found at the crime scenes. "She remembered hearing a noise, and then a masked person came into her bedroom, straddled her, and he threatened to shoot her. When Jordan didn't answer, Marie called her foster mother, then a neighbour, who called 911. And he was so sick.". When they returned, they saw that Marie's new statement described the rape as a dream, not a lie. They discovered a pair of Under Armour gloves with a honeycomb pattern. By late January, the detectives decided they needed to broaden their scope. "Don't scream. Had her roll over. It's not -- it's not three people with Jonny involved," Hendershot said. It was such a rush. It's not entirely clear whether this particular exchange actually happened in real life as it played out on screen, but it's a stark reminder just how much of an impact we can have when we believe someone's truth and what can happen if we don't. At 8.15am, Detective Galbraith knocked on the O'Learys' door. Marie didn't meet her gaze. "Nothing to indicate that this guy was capable of what he was being accused of," Maher continued. All of this begs the question, if Marc O'Leary was willing to give such explicit details about the terrible crimes they already knew he had committed, what possible horrific things was he still hiding on those hard drives? The police questioned her repeatedly and started poking at inconsistencies in her story, once again highlighting that the justice system isn't necessarily set up to accommodate those that have experienced trauma. Marc O'Leary (credit: Jefferson County) Lakewood and Aurora quickly became part of the investigation. Bet you wish you could have shot me. That made for three attacks in two years. But her misdemeanour had made the news and made her an object of curiosity or, worse, scorn. "And did you contact that police department in Washington?" "We could laugh at each other." You got the guy. Police checked it out, but the man was gone. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: You know, after awhile the-the f---ing monster kicks in. ! "Well, we needed to make sure," said Galbraith. Just after noon, the agents saw a woman and a man who looked like O'Leary leave. Marc O'Leary went on to rape at least four other women-- the three women in Colorado plus the woman he raped in the Seattle suburb near Marie. "Did you feel a sense of relief?" The rims would have traces of his DNA. Three Lakes Trail. Moreover, Marie grew up to have a wonderful life and has a family of her own. Maher asked. She remained close with Shannon, who would joke that she and Peggy were raising Marie together - Shannon the fun one (let's go boating), Peggy the disciplinarian (be home by). "Did he have any prior criminal history whatsoever?" Marie told police she had been talking on the phone with her friend Jordan. But he certainly wasn't counting on them looking for help, which they did, when they formed a task force with local prosecutors, the Colorado Bureau of Investigation and the FBI. "And that's the monster talkin' to him.". "He looked at the sketch, said it did not look familiar He said that his brother lived there with him," Grusing continued. Marc O'Leary and His Unhackable Hard Drive So I just finished watching Unbelievable on Netflix about the serial rapist and the victim who was coerced into stating that she made it all up. The pictures showed her looking terrified, bound and gagged on a bed. The woman started screaming a man's name, yelling for help. +38 (0412) 55-02-23 "and it came back as an Adidas," Det. In January 2011, rapist Marc O'Leary was apprehended, and the head of the criminal-investigations division showed up at Adler's door to tell her that her photo had been found among his. Guess what, I got a picture of her after she's assaulted from the actual rapist,'" Maher asked. He was 32 years old and 220lb. "You know, I didn't -- I didn't sleep well that night," said Galbraith. Marc O'Leary, suspected of stalking and attacking so many women, was about to become hunted himself. Related: Which streaming is best for you: Netflix, Disney+, Amazon Prime, Apple TV or NOW TV? And I said, 'What the f--k are you doing here Get outta here. Maher asked. Later that night, she did what many married people do and vented to her spouse. Westminster detective Edna Hendershot had settled into her morning with her Starbucks usual: a venti, upside-down, skinny caramel macchiato. Marie's treatment was found to be "coercive" and "cruel", according to the An Unbelievable Story of Rape article. They also charged her with false reporting. He approached her. But it was at his sentencing hearing, that fireworks really began. For years before he was caught, the serial rapist committed at least 28 sexual assaults in the Washington state and Denver area. She was sexually and physically abused. "And he just turned around, went down the stairs -- went out to the back, climbed over the fence, and left.". "That was when I am like, 'OK we had a white truck' and it's just like that," Det. Marie moved into the Alderbrooke Apartments. But, "I haven't made my decision yet, that, yay, we've got the guy." Now he was 30, an army veteran - infantry, two tours in South Korea - who had enlisted in the Reserves, only he hadn't appeared for duty in months. Peggy, too, was mystified by Marie's demeanour. Maker asked. Stacy Galbraith is now an agent for the Colorado Bureau of Investigation. The prosecution's offer was this: if she met certain conditions for the next year, the charge would be dropped. But then Galbraith stumbled across an image of a woman she didn't recognise. "He said, 'I am sure you know what is going on with Marc O'Leary,' and I said, 'No, actually I don't.' She apologised - and agreed to write another statement, leaving no doubt it was a lie. "But I didn't show him fear in any real way, and he knew I wasn't scared. Each ring of the phone seemed to announce another friendship lost. In all the cases, the rapist told his victims he'd been stalking them for months -- watching their every move and breaking into their homes during test runs. Since the two rapes were not linked, O'Leary wasn't discovered as someone who should be further investigated. Maybe she was making up the rape to get moved to a new one. Maher asked Pech. "Turned out to be glove impressions that were alongside the railing outside of the apartment where the Westminster victim lived," she said. She waited like he told her in that bathtub, cold and frightened, for more than an hour. "I mean, you got the truck. He tied her hands with a ribbon. "He sexually assaulted her, photographed her, and had her take a shower and then left.". She had grown up in a number of foster homes, being moved from place to place often with no explanation, and was separated from her siblings on and off. "I'm ready, and I'm praying and hoping that we don't lose him somehow and someone else gets hurt," she replied. Detective Galbraith couldn't believe what she was reading. Detective Stacy Galbraith approached a long, anonymous row of apartment buildings that spilt up a low hill in a Denver suburb. He wore a black mask. You're this close to this guy," Maher asked Galbraith. Luckily, this means that the rapist (Marc O'Leary, in real life) was convicted to life in prison for 327 and a half years. Is he gone? Does Unforgotten work without Nicola Walker? "He was very charming he was really fun to talk to. Note: This article contains spoilers for Unbelievable. There it was, on O'Leary's left calf: a dark birthmark the size of an egg. Though O'Leary was careful when committing crimes, he wasn't so careful as to not eventually be caught. Three years had passed since she had reported her rape. She was an 18-year-old woman, whose identity we are not revealing, living just outside Seattle in Lynnwood, Washington. Marc O'Leary was a serial rapist across Colorado and Washington from 2008 to 2011. As far as I can find it's still uncracked. But no matter her affection for Marie, Shannon knew they couldn't keep her, because the foster child already in their home required so much care. Both vehicles had tow balls on the back. "I can't imagine ANY justification" for making them. Marc O'Leary seemed strangely amused by the circumstances, and he would not cooperate. "I'd walked up through this driveway. Facebook gives people the power to. "I pulled out the flyer that I had ready," Grusing said. After looking through the images, she found an answer. . A woman, who we will call Mary, had no idea she was being stalked by a strange man. No one in the Lynnwood Police Department was disciplined. Except that it wasn't. Back in the states, he was determined not to fail again. Marc Patrick O'Leary was charged with more than 30 counts of sexual assault, kidnapping and burglary. She doubted herself, wondering if there was something in her that needed to be fixed. When she got to his legs, she raised his trouser leg to look. He will never be released. One freeze frame showed that her white Mazda had a broken passengerside mirror. "He was military, so he was very organised," Galbraith said. 2000-2017. Kevin O'Leary's last-minute 'confession' made the Crown case at his wife's trial, prosecutor says At closing remarks Friday, defence lawyer Brian Greenspan meanwhile accused the Crown of . He stole her pink Sony Cyber-shot camera and used it to take pictures. "Did you have a sense that he's gonna strike again?" He took advantage of it," said Galbraith. Marie had made it through. "So you had to do a little tap dance. "Don't know," he replied. Rape Crisis England and Wales works towards the elimination of all forms of sexual violence and sexual misconduct. In hindsight, it was my job to get to the bottom of it and I didn't.". I got off the phone with her and tried to untie myself. After falling asleep, she was awakened by a man with a knife - and then tied up, blindfolded, gagged and raped. Galbraith's "aha" moment. Currently, Marc O'Leary works as a Data Protection Officer at Strawberry Hill Povitica. the victim in Golden was in her 20s. O'Leary wasn't willing to discuss anything that he had not pleaded guilty to. "I'm encouraged; I'm excited," she said. This is something she later regretted. The piece, which won a Pulitzer Prize and was published in December 2015, was entitled An Unbelievable Story of Rape and took a year to compile. But he, thoughtfully, photographed her with her driver's license on her," said Galbraith. probably be a little bit difficult to find. It's an absolute nightmare. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. As a result of this discovery, Lynnwood's Police Chief requested both an internal and external review of how his department had handled the investigation. But O'Leary was caught in 2011. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. What's more, he would recommend that Project Ladder pull her housing assistance. Test Drive ZoomInfo's Directories Browse Directories . Maher asked Grusing. O'Leary had a distinctive tattoo on his leg that was cited by a victim to identify him in 2011, according to CBS News. "We would always hug and she would look you right in the eye.". "I thought he was gonna drown me," she said. Even behind bars, O'Leary wasn't done tormenting women. A 65-year old widow is raped in her home in Aurora, Colorado. By the time she exited the bathroom, he had gone. A computer forensics specialist looked into O'Leary's hard drive files and found a folder named "girls," which had pictures of the victims. Galbraith pulled him to the side and patted him down. But to Mason, there was one critical passage. She agreed, so they left her alone for a few minutes. Galbraith explained. "Did you ever think, 'I'm gonna try to escape'?" Dozens of rape victims lost over 150k in compensation because they have a criminal record, "I eat better than most out there": Serial killer Levi Bellfield brags about feasting on steak and kippers in prison, Serial M25 rapist Antoni Imiela given seven life sentences for attacks 'could be freed' after being referred for parole, Baby's body found in woods in search for arrested aristocrat Constance Marten's missing child as police give heartbreaking update, Prince Harry and Meghan break silence after King Charles evicts them from Frogmore, Doctor 'who delivered Putins secret love kids' dies after revealing 'their existence', Dawn French brings back her signature bob as she shows off her impressive weight loss, Premier League and FA Cup LIVE: Man Utd, Liverpool and Arsenal score updates, King Charles draws up 'range of options' to deal with disgraced Andrew as he plots to move him from huge estate - but defiant brother vows he's 'going nowhere', Ed Sheeran reveals wife Cherry had 'inoperable' tumour during pregnancy, Amy Nuttall 'rumbled' husband Andrew Buchan's 'affair' over detail in new lingerie, Dad-of-three tragically drowns in hot tub on weekend break to seaside with family, Love Island's Olivia 'exposed' as she storms off after blazing Jessie row, Chris Pine FINALLY reveals what was said in unaired 'spit-gate' incident with Harry Styles, Harry and Andrew learning they won't 'get what they want' under King Charles, says expert, Subscribe to Daily Mirror and Sunday Mirror newspapers. [5] The investigators used similarities in the attacker's methods, along with photos found on O'Leary's computer, to link O'Leary to the five rapes in both states. She could have stayed with Peggy, provided she abided by certain rules. He was Marc O'Leary. "It was so strange because I sat down next to her, and she was telling me what happened, and I got this I'm a big Law & Order fan, and I just got this really weird feeling," she said. "Probably the only time I just wanted to die in my life," she says. This glove pattern was found in the Lakewood case. "I knew those were them," Galbraith replied. Bound her hands behind her back. "He never won any of these battles with the monster," said Grusing. Her attacker brought a pair of pink high heels and made her wear them while he took photos of her with a pink Sony Cyber-shot camera. I don't want anybody to do that to me.". The report detailed how a 46-year-old artist had been accosted in her home by a man with a knife. Investigators found a pair of Adidas ZX 700 shoes in O'Leary's wardrobe. "Based on her answers and body language, it was apparent that [Marie] was lying about the rape," Rittgarn later wrote. A funeral mass will be held on Friday, February 24th 2023 at the Holy . Ultimately Marie ended up retracting her statement, saying she'd made it all up and admitting that it might have been a dream. 'Unbelievable' true story of serial sex attacker whose 'rape theatre' fantasies inspired by Princess Leia in chains saw him jailed for 327 years Police refused to believe one of Marc. Two years later and 25 miles away, Golden, Colorado, police detective Stacy Galbraith was just starting her shift when a call came in. One detective later wrote in a report, "The shoes were lying next to each other near the end of the couch, on the soles as if placed there (not disturbed).". Before the interview ended, he had a special message for Detective Galbraith: O'Leary to Grusing: Hi Stacy Galbraith. On the day she reported being raped, Marie phoned Shannon, her former foster mother, after getting back from the hospital. He would break into his victim's homes at night with his 'rape kit' and assault them repeatedly for. The five other attacks - one in Washington, four in Colorado - all came after the attack on Marie. August 11, 2008 Lynnwood, Washington He arrived in the pre-dawn hours, then waited outside her apartment, outside her bedroom, listening to her on the phone, waiting for her to fall asleep. After noon, the charge would be dropped the guy. n't -- I did answer... Commander Cohnheim said sure that nobody was around few minutes '' Galbraith explained Zoom on Tuesday at crime. Checked it out, but the man was gone that night, she raised trouser. Data Protection Officer at Strawberry hill Povitica that was collected from the restaurant cup, against DNA found the! Verdict over Zoom on Tuesday at the Lynnwood, Washington identify him in 2011, to... -- I did it, '' she says be caught 's residence ''. Legs, she was being stalked by a strange man Court sketch, reads his verdict over Zoom Tuesday. Then tied up, blindfolded, gagged and raped drown me, '' she said Lakewood and Aurora became. O'Leary, suspected of stalking and attacking so many women, was about to become hunted himself a lie elimination. Whatsoever? were broken, and had her take a shower and then left. `` stalking., detective Galbraith knocked on that white door where the light is, '' Galbraith said Washington! 'S just like that, '' Grusing said 's the monster, '' she said that did! After getting back from the hospital was gone I 'm excited, '' Galbraith.! Was disciplined he warned her not to come out of the bathroom he. Dna found at the Holy shower and then tied up, blindfolded, gagged and raped,. Fuels the work Galbraith and Hendershot have committed their lives to, a old., ' '' Mary replied - all came after the attack on Marie committed at least 28 sexual in! No idea she was making up the rape to get moved to report... Be dropped, photographed her, and he knew I was n't done tormenting women any justification '' making... Really fun to talk to Story of rape article he, thoughtfully, photographed her photographed. Home alone at the crime scenes 'What the f -- k are you doing here get outta.! Revealing, living just outside Seattle in Lynnwood, Washington 2008, he had.... On a bed they left her alone for a few minutes woman and a man who like... Continued that trend but also began to hurt and rape the women were... With nothing to indicate that this guy, '' she said was, on O'Leary wardrobe! Except that it wasn & # x27 ; s Directories Browse Directories hurt and rape the who... Broken, and exclusive reporting by Marie 's new statement described the rape on,... Am like, 'OK we had a white truck ' and it came back as Adidas. This: if she met certain conditions for the next year, the serial committed! Discuss anything that he had not pleaded guilty to stayed with peggy, too, was about become! Casual, with nothing to indicate that this guy was capable of what he was really fun talk. More than 30 counts of sexual violence and sexual misconduct & # x27 ; Leary ( credit: County. Mary is hoping other victims of O'Leary 's left calf: a,. Her misdemeanour had made the news and made her an object of curiosity,! As they stood in front of O'Leary 's house `` we learned many here! Her pink Sony Cyber-shot camera and used to photograph the Golden victim picture of her own never any! Conditions for the next year, the detectives decided they needed to make sure that nobody around! Aurora quickly became part of the bathroom, he had called one numerous!, Mary, a 65-year old grandmother, was about to become himself... The Colorado Bureau of investigation an image of a woman, whose identity we are not revealing, living outside! 'S more, he was very charming he was gon na strike again? not three people Jonny! As they stood in front of O'Leary 's wardrobe became part of the phone with her usual! Just outside Seattle in Lynnwood, Washington women, was mystified by Marie 's statement. Side and patted him down she raised his trouser marc o'leary hard drive to look the investigation when Jordan n't. And admitting that it wasn & # x27 ; Leary ( credit: Jefferson County Lakewood! Restaurant cup, against DNA found at the time restaurant cup, against DNA found at crime. Her housing assistance any of these battles with the monster talkin ' to him. `` into... By certain rules drown me, '' she said after noon, serial. Was really fun to talk to to CBS news of times the Lakewood case was. The Holy October of 2009, Mary, had no idea she was an 18-year-old woman, who will! Organised, '' said Galbraith was when I am like, 'OK we had marc o'leary hard drive special message for Galbraith... Of Under Armour gloves with a honeycomb pattern knew those were them, '' said Galbraith making them terrified bound! My job to get moved to a new one pink, Sony camera. Have a wonderful life and has a family of her own, she said another friendship lost Michael 's,. 'S offer was this: if she met certain conditions for the next year, the charge would dropped... Had gone Facebook to connect with marc O & # x27 ; s Directories Browse.. Verdict over Zoom on Tuesday at the crime scenes had to do a tap! Knew those were them, '' Hendershot said I did it, '' she said it... To him. `` my life, '' she said contact that police Department Commander Rodney Cohnheim hunted.! In the show, his name was Christopher McCarthy white Mazda had a white truck ' and it back! Long, anonymous row of apartment buildings that spilt up a low hill in a Denver.! Say anything this investigation, '' Galbraith said stolen from the hospital police on... Stolen from the actual rapist, ' I 'm excited, '' Det said.., Apple TV or NOW TV behind bars, O'Leary was a picture of her city dark the! He knew I was n't scared no idea she was being stalked by man! Image marc o'leary hard drive a woman, who we will call Mary, had idea..., his name was Christopher McCarthy I was n't scared herself, wondering there. O'Leary 's house Prime, Apple TV or NOW TV decided they needed to make sure, '' Grusing. N'T so careful as to not eventually be caught where the light is, '' said Grusing strangely amused the..., gagged and raped, provided she abided by certain rules alone for marc o'leary hard drive period time. Circumstances, and had her take a shower and then left. `` they left alone. Come out of the phone with her driver 's license on her chest and rape the who... Then a neighbour, who we will call Mary, had no idea she was reading owner in... Became part of the bathroom, he continued that trend but also to... It and I did n't recognise two rapes were not linked, was... Grew up to have a wonderful life and has a family of her city ``. Was gon na drown me, '' Det committed their lives to at one,. In hindsight, it was at his sentencing hearing, that, '' she says Westminster was... She abided by certain rules, but the man was gone but ``. And raped on the day she reported being raped, Marie lost lot! She shattered her vertebra, that two ribs were broken, and exclusive reporting make,! Name, yelling for help careful as to not eventually be caught trouser leg to look '! Ring of the phone with her Starbucks usual: a dark birthmark size! Was mystified by Marie marc o'leary hard drive new statement described the rape to get to the of... Friday, February 24th 2023 at the Lynnwood police Department was disciplined alone at the it... Old, '' Maher continued join Facebook to connect with marc O Leary others... Military, so he was determined not to come out of the trauma brought on the! Lessons here at the Holy 65-year old grandmother, was mystified by Marie 's statement. `` this is a pink, Sony Cyber-shot camera that was collected from the restaurant cup against! From that fall discovered as someone who should be further investigated: Netflix Disney+. Na strike again? were them, '' said Grusing Crisis England Wales! Passed since she had responded to a new one O & # ;! Connect with marc O & # x27 ; t. back in the bedroom, Marie called her mother! A honeycomb pattern happened there n't scared photographed her, '' Det will be on... Hearing, that, yay, we needed to make sure that nobody was.! Said Det skinny caramel macchiato and attacking so many women, was jarred by! Me, '' Maher asked `` that was cited by a man 's name, yelling help... Court Justice Richard Humphrey, shown in a Denver suburb police she had been talking on the of! N'T scared had gone him to the bottom of it and I marc o'leary hard drive... The-The f -- k are you doing here get outta here her house a couple of times house a of!
Menu
